What are the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil?
Uncertain Outcomes
A lawsuit in Brazil can bring significant uncertainty. Judges exercise broad discretion when weighing the facts, which means each case may unfold differently. Even with strong evidence, it’s possible for a court to decide in favor of the opposing party. The Brazilian judiciary follows the Civil Law tradition, but judges often interpret statutes and precedent in ways that surprise foreign and domestic litigants. This unpredictability pushes many businesses to think twice before pursuing litigation, since they might not recover the damages they expect. Assessing the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil is crucial before moving forward.
Time and Resource Commitment
Court proceedings in Brazil can take years before a final judgment is issued. Parties must devote funds and staff to assemble documents, attend hearings, and respond to the court’s requests. This can feel burdensome for smaller companies or individuals, who may not have large legal teams to handle the workload. The delays sometimes lead to a loss of focus on other important matters, such as growing the business or resolving conflicts amicably. Even with diligent tracking, there is always the risk of sinking time and money into a lawsuit that doesn’t deliver the desired outcome. Success fees or contingency-based arrangements are not always easy to secure in Brazilian litigation, which makes the financial investment more pressing. Considering the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil, smaller entities might look for alternative solutions.
Losing Party Attorney Fees
In many Brazilian disputes, the losing side is ordered to pay the opposing side’s attorney fees, commonly known as “honorários de sucumbência.” These fees can reach up to 20% of the awarded amount. Courts have considerable leeway to set the percentage, but it must stay within the limits set by procedural rules. That money goes straight to the attorneys rather than to the prevailing party. This system can surprise foreign clients, who may assume that any recovery includes reimbursement of legal costs. The risk of paying these fees can discourage people from taking a case to trial unless they have very strong grounds. This adds another layer to the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil.
Difficulty of Enforcing Judgments
Winning a lawsuit in Brazil does not always translate into a quick payout. Enforcing judgments can become a separate battle. If the party ordered to pay refuses or dissolves its assets, the prevailing side might see little or no compensation. Some businesses even resort to shutting down operations or transferring assets to avoid judgment enforcement. This adds another layer of uncertainty and may encourage parties to negotiate or explore alternative dispute resolution methods, such as arbitration or mediation. The difficulties in enforcing judgments are a key aspect of the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil.
Reputational Risk
Court filings in Brazil are often part of public records. Publicizing a dispute can harm your standing with business partners or clients who watch for signs of instability or conflict. Investors may think twice about backing a company tied up in long lawsuits. In some sectors, any publicity linked to a legal battle can damage brand image. Clients searching for reliable partners might hesitate when they see ongoing litigation or a history of courtroom entanglements. This reputational risk can be especially troublesome for professionals offering services in an already competitive market. Among the various risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil, the impact on reputation is sometimes underestimated.
Keeping these risks in mind, many parties choose to weigh alternative strategies before jumping into litigation. Talking through the potential downsides with a knowledgeable attorney who understands disputes in Brazil is often the best first step. Each case brings unique challenges, and a thorough risk assessment can prevent unwelcome surprises along the way. Always consider the risks of filing a lawsuit in Brazil before making a final decision.
Watch our video here: