Force an Accounting in Brazil: Make a Partner, Manager, Agent, or Estate Administrator Show the Books

You trusted someone in Brazil with your money, your property, your business, or an estate — a partner, a rental manager, someone holding your power of attorney, the administrator of a family estate — and now you cannot get a straight, documented explanation of what came in and what went out.
Where the legal requirements are met, Brazilian law provides a way to demand accounts and establish an enforceable balance. This guide, for foreign clients, explains how it works and which situation is yours.
This page is general information about accounting and financial-management disputes in Brazil. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Procedures and requirements change over time, and only a formal consultation with a lawyer licensed in Brazil, reviewing your specific facts, can tell you how the law applies to your situation.
Reviewed by Luciano Oliveira, Esq., LL.M. — attorney admitted in Brazil, Texas, and California. Last reviewed July 2026.
Content updated: October 30, 2026.
What “forcing an accounting” means in Brazil
The tool is the ação de exigir contas — an action to demand accounts (still widely called by its older name, ação de prestação de contas).
Where a duty and the appropriate procedural basis exist, it requires a person who managed another’s money or assets to produce a detailed, documented account: what they received, what they spent, what they kept, and what is left.
It may be appropriate when you cannot obtain adequate accounts of another person’s management. Suspicion alone does not establish every requirement for the action. Identify the relationship, period, transactions and dispute; producing particular documents may sometimes be the better route.
Who has a legal duty to account to you
Not everyone owes you an accounting. The right claimant, the manager’s role, the assets and the legal relationship must be identified. That duty can come from a contract or directly from the law, and it typically covers:
- a business partner or company administrator (sócio / administrador) who runs the business or holds its money;
- someone holding your power of attorney (procurador) who managed or sold assets on your behalf;
- a property or rental manager collecting rent and paying expenses on your Brazilian property;
- the administrator of an estate (inventariante), who must account to the heirs;
- a court-appointed guardian (tutor or curador) managing another person’s assets;
- and, more broadly, anyone who in fact held and managed your funds.
A foreign trust is not automatically treated as a domestic Brazilian trust arrangement. If a trustee or foreign estate is involved, the governing instrument, applicable law, assets and jurisdiction need separate analysis. See our foreign trusts and estates guide.
Two directions: demanding accounts vs. rendering them
You, as the person owed an explanation, can demand accounts to force disclosure. The person who did the managing can instead render accounts on their own initiative, to seek approval of their management. The procedural route is not necessarily the same as an action demanding accounts; court-appointed administrators have specific rules.
The resulting balance can favor either party — the court awards any resulting balance to whichever party it favors, so you are not limited to proving a number in advance.
How it works: the two phases (and why it can recover money)
An ordinary action demanding accounts commonly unfolds in two stages, when the duty itself needs to be determined:
- First, the court decides a narrow question: does this person owe you an accounting at all? You do not need to prove fraud first, but the claimant must establish the applicable duty and procedural interest.
- Then, if the duty is confirmed, the accounts themselves are examined line by line, checked against receipts and statements, and the court fixes a balance.
For ordinary claims, refusal or delay, disagreement with accounts supplied, or a disputed balance can establish the need for judicial intervention. A prior request is useful evidence, but it is not an indispensable requirement in every case. Statutory accounting duties, including estate administration, require separate treatment.
The decision fixing the balance is an enforceable judgment. If it shows money is owed to you, it becomes a title you can collect on — so the action can actually recover a proven balance, not only produce transparency.
Actual recovery still depends on enforcement, available assets and any applicable defenses. The balance may belong to a company or estate rather than to the individual requesting accounts.
Find your situation
“My Brazilian business partner won’t show me the books.”
You co-own a business in Brazil, the other partner runs it, and you cannot get the financials or a clear picture of the money.
The right to demand an accounting depends on the company structure, your standing and the management period. Where the evidence supports it, recovery or a partner exit or removal may also be appropriate. Accounts already approved and applicable time limits must be assessed.
“The manager collecting my rent won’t account for it.”
You own property in Brazil managed by an agency or an individual who collects the rent and pays the bills. They owe you a periodic, documented account of what came in, what was spent, and their fees.
When the rent stops arriving or the numbers don’t add up, a properly supported accounting claim can require an itemized explanation and supporting records.
“My power-of-attorney holder misused or won’t explain my funds.”
You gave someone a power of attorney (procuração) to handle a sale or manage assets in Brazil, and money is missing or unexplained.
An agent ordinarily must account for their management. The mandate and any legally applicable exception must be checked; a special mandate in the agent’s own interest is not the same as an ordinary agency. This often pairs with revoking the power of attorney and, where funds were diverted, recovering them.
“The estate administrator won’t account to the heirs.”
A relative or co-heir is running a family estate in Brazil as inventariante and won’t tell the other heirs what the estate holds or where the money has gone. Heirs can demand an accounting — and, where the administrator won’t account or has mismanaged the estate, seek their removal through the appropriate procedure.
The administrator’s duty comes from statute. CPC Articles 553 and 618(VII) provide for accounts connected with the appointment proceeding and when the administrator leaves office or the judge orders them. The STJ has distinguished this statutory duty from an ordinary claim requiring a first phase to establish the duty.
A separate first phase is not required merely to prove a duty already imposed by law.
Do not assume that every accounting request can be made incidentally after removal. The procedural route and limitation period must be checked; a separate action may be needed. Removal is not automatic. For the wider estate dispute, see inheritance disputes in Brazil.
“A guardian is managing a relative’s assets without accounting.”
Where a court-appointed guardian (tutor or curador) manages the assets of a minor or an incapacitated relative, the applicable guardianship rules, court orders and statutory exceptions govern their accounting obligations. Failing to account can support appropriate protective or removal measures; replacement is not automatic.
Related paths, when an accounting isn’t quite the right tool
Sometimes a different action fits better, and we choose the right combination:
- to simply see specific records — an action to produce documents;
- to exit or expel a partner and value the stake — a partial dissolution and buyout;
- to remove an estate administrator who won’t account — their removal;
- to limit further use of an ordinary mandate, where legally effective — revoking the power of attorney;
- and where you already know a sum was taken — a straight collection or fraud claim with asset tracing.
Why this is different when you are abroad
Distance can make it harder to obtain records and monitor the person managing your money. We act for clients in the United States and elsewhere — filing and running the action in Brazil, gathering the financial evidence, and coordinating with your home-country advisors, including when a recovered balance has to be enforced or moved across borders.
Many steps can be handled through Brazilian counsel. A court may still require personal testimony or another act; remote participation depends on the applicable order and arrangements. Do not assume that appointing counsel removes every attendance requirement.
Evidence to prepare
Start with the contract or power of attorney that created the duty, bank statements, transfer records, message trails, and a clear timeline of what you entrusted and what you received.
Keep requests for accounts, responses and any specific discrepancies. Assembling this early — even from abroad — helps define the period, the transactions and the relief to request. Avoid accessing accounts or confidential records without lawful authority.
Someone in Brazil won’t account for your money? We can help.
Or write to [email protected]
Frequently asked questions
Can I force someone in Brazil to show me the books?
Where the legal requirements are met, an accounting claim can compel documented accounts. An ordinary claim requires the applicable duty and procedural interest; statutory estate-administration duties have their own rules. Proof of fraud is not a prerequisite.
Do I have to be in Brazil to bring an accounting action?
Many steps can be handled through Brazilian counsel while you remain abroad. A court may require personal testimony or another act, so attendance and any remote arrangements must be assessed in the case.
Can I actually get my money back, or just see the accounts?
Both are possible. A judgment fixing a balance is enforceable, but actual recovery depends on the evidence, the proper recipient of the balance, available assets and enforcement.
The other side won't respond at all. Does that help or hurt me?
Silence is not automatic proof of diversion or of the amount claimed. Under CPC Article 550, a defendant who fails to provide accounts after an order may lose the right to challenge the claimant’s accounts. Those accounts still require supporting documents and judicial examination.
Is this a fraud case or a civil one?
It is a civil action to compel accounts and fix a balance. Separate recovery or criminal measures require their own factual and legal basis; an accounting dispute does not by itself establish a crime.
A partner, agent, or estate administrator in Brazil who won’t account? We can help.
Or write to [email protected]
Related: Debt collection & enforcement · Business & commercial litigation · Financial power of attorney in Brazil · Inherited property & forced heirship · Brazil lawsuit monitoring · How lawsuits work in Brazil · Litigation & dispute resolution hub
Legal references
- Civil Code, Articles 668, 685, 1,020, 1,755–1,757 and 1,783: management duties and relevant exceptions.
- Code of Civil Procedure, Articles 550–553 and 618–624: accounting, estate-administrator duties and removal.
- STJ guidance on procedural interest: an ordinary accounting claim needs a controversy; a prior request is one way to show it.
- STJ REsp 1,931,806/RJ: an estate administrator’s statutory accounting duty.
- STJ REsp 1,941,686/MG: the route for seeking accounts after removal.

