Suppose your company hires a developer in São Paulo. She works from home, invoices you through her Brazilian company, and gets paid in dollars. Two years later she leaves and claims paid vacation and a thirteenth salary. Your finance director finds the signed services agreement. I would also want to speak with her manager. When she wanted a Friday off, did she tell him when the work would be ready, or did she need his permission?
On November 13, Folha de S.Paulo reported that Justice Gilmar Mendes of Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court favors letting Brazilian labor judges decide, case by case, whether these arrangements disguise employment.
If your company uses the same contract for a whole team in Brazil, one former contractor’s claim is a good reason to look at how you manage the others.
What a Brazilian Labor Judge Can Hear Today
PJ stands for pessoa jurídica, a legal entity. In a typical PJ arrangement, the professional signs through their own company and that company bills yours. Brazilian law allows genuine independent contracting. In a dispute over what Brazilians call pejotização, the professional claims that the day-to-day relationship amounted to employment.
Mendes was speaking at a conference. The full Court still has to decide which courts should hear claims of fraud, when PJ hiring is lawful, and who must prove fraud. In the meantime, a June order lets trial and regional labor courts hear evidence and issue decisions. A covered case pauses after the regional court rules.
If your Brazilian representative receives a hearing notice, send it to counsel immediately. Your opportunity to put the manager’s account on the record may come well before the Supreme Court settles the issue.
What Your Manager Might Say at the Hearing
A client can set a delivery date, ask for progress reports, and send back defective work. Now suppose the developer had to log in at nine every morning, do the work personally, and stay online until her manager in Dallas released her.
Those facts help a judge assess whether she regularly performed paid work under the company’s direction. Brazilian labor law expressly recognizes supervision by electronic means. A manager in Dallas can exercise that control over someone in São Paulo.
I would ask to see an ordinary week of messages. If the contract lets the developer choose her hours but her manager gave her a written warning for logging in late, expect her lawyer to ask about that warning.
If fifteen developers received the same instructions, have Brazilian counsel estimate the exposure across the team. Depending on the facts, it may include a thirteenth salary, vacation pay plus one-third, severance fund deposits (FGTS), overtime, and termination payments.
When One Complaint Puts the Whole Team Under Review
Those fifteen developers do not each have to bring a claim for your hiring practices to come under scrutiny. A complaint about one team can prompt Brazil’s labor prosecutors, the Ministério Público do Trabalho (MPT), to investigate how the company hires and supervises the others.
The MPT can negotiate an enforceable agreement to change those practices or bring a public civil action asking a court to stop the practice and award damages for harm to workers as a group. Settling with the first developer resolves her claim. It does not close an MPT investigation.
What a Claimant Can Collect in Brazil
Your company may have assets in Brazil even if it has no office or bank account there. Say a Brazilian customer owes your U.S. company for a shipment. A court enforcing a judgment against your company can attach that receivable and direct the customer to withhold payment.
The first person at headquarters to notice may be the controller waiting for the wire. If the company does own a Brazilian bank account, a court can freeze funds up to the amount sought.
Who Speaks for Your Company in Brazil
Check who can receive court papers for you. Under Brazilian procedural law, the manager of a foreign company’s local branch or agency is presumed to have that authority. A different question arises at the hearing.
The person you designate to represent the company can bind it by what they say about the facts. Choose someone who actually knows how the team worked.
Also read the power of attorney you signed for Brazilian counsel. Accepting initial service and settling a case require specific authority. If you granted settlement authority, your lawyer can commit the company to a payment within the terms of that mandate. The company owes that payment. A claimant would need a separate legal basis to go after the representative’s or lawyer’s own assets.
When Collection Makes Economic Sense Abroad
If the company’s assets are in Texas, a worker with a final, conclusive, enforceable Brazilian money judgment can ask a Texas court to recognize the compensation award. The company can contest recognition on grounds that include lack of jurisdiction in Brazil or insufficient notice to defend the case.
Once recognized, the award can be enforced against company assets in Texas. If your assets are elsewhere, the claimant must look to the recognition rules that apply there.
It takes only one worker to pursue payment abroad. What changes with a larger Brazilian team is the cost calculation. A modest award may barely cover translations and local counsel. Several substantial awards against the same company give claimants a financial reason to find out what it owns back home.
Before you renew the next PJ contract, ask the manager to show you the last time someone on the team declined an assignment or took a day off.
If the job requires fixed shifts and close supervision, put that to Brazilian counsel directly. You want to know what it would cost to employ the person properly and what the company may already owe for the time they have worked.
Further Reading
- Folha de S.Paulo Read what Justice Mendes said in São Paulo and why his remarks drew attention.
- Ministério Público do Trabalho Read what labor prosecutors asked a Brazilian court to order in an actual PJ case.
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, Ch. 36A Sections 36A.003–.004 explain which foreign awards qualify and when recognition may be refused.

